A Dallas, Texas, area pastor was sentenced to 35 years for stealing three church buildings. Dallas County Criminal District Attorney John Creuzot announced the conviction of Witney Foster.
Foster, who led a small congregation without a physical place to gather, was accused of stealing real estate from three churches. Foster filed fraudulent deeds, listing a fake leader for the victim churches as the grantors and naming his church in his own name as the grantee. The combined value of the stolen properties exceeds $800,000.
The affected churches are First Christian Church of Lancaster and, in Dallas, Canada Drive Christian Church and Church at Nineveh. Two of the three properties are still under the defendant’s or his church’s name, with his congregation actively gathering at one of them. The third property remains embroiled in legal complications caused by Foster's actions.
Lead Prosecutor Phillip Clark said, “Property ownership is a bedrock of our society – it provides security, a home, a place to love and welcome each other. It also represents a very active part of our economy, both in terms of buying, selling, and renting property, as well as property taxes that support everything our government does for the citizens of Dallas County. Deed Fraud cases are not simply disputes; they are lies and fraud – they are theft – and they are deeply damaging. I’m so grateful that the jury saw the truth in this case and held the defendant to account.”
During the punishment phase of the trial, the jury was presented with evidence of seven additional fraudulent deeds displaying the same characteristics as the three charged deeds. Additionally, they were informed of Foster's prior convictions, which include Identity Theft and Arson.
Creuzot thanked Clark who specializes in Deed Fraud cases. He also thanked ADA Melinda Chaney and DA Investigator Hoyt Hoffman, along with the Lancaster Police Department and the jury for upholding their oath to follow the law.